Stream of Photos or Moving Story?

Why Video Slideshows Need Storytelling

Video slideshows don’t hold people’s attention like they used to. It wasn’t that long ago when you’d look forward to seeing a photo slideshow at a wedding, an anniversary, or a milestone birthday party. Show a slideshow at a gathering like that now and look around to see who’s watching and who decided it’s time to go to the bathroom or check their phones.

Photo montage slideshows used to be a novelty that people enjoyed. When my daughter was in dance more than 20 years ago, everyone looked forward to the end-of-year slideshow of the graduating seniors. Even if I didn’t know the kids, I would tear up watching the passage of time through the photos that were shared and imagine what it would be like when my daughter’s pictures were up on the screen.

Turns out that I didn’t get to experience the senior slideshow because my daughter skipped her senior year of high school. “Oh, you’ll miss out on the dance slideshow,” was the first thing my sister said to me when she heard that my daughter was going to college a year early.

I was indeed disappointed about missing out on the dance slideshow, but I made up for it when my daughter got married. I made a 10-minute three-chapter video about the two of them growing up and as a couple. The show was a hit back in 2007, but when I did the same thing for my son and his bride in 2017, I was surprised and a bit annoyed when the hum in the room increased as people paid more attention to their own conversations than the stream of photos on the screen.

What happened in 10 years to change the way people respond to wedding slideshows? One word – smartphones. When smartphones took off as the go-to device for taking pictures, we could suddenly take more photos than ever before because we always had a camera along. And it’s not just our own photos that we had more of. There was more to look at from our family and friends and that saturation led to image overload.

I wonder about the impact of our increased exposure to visual information. Has our attention become more limited than it was before we became exposed to a constant photo stream? Is a slideshow a rehash of what we’ve already seen on social media? Have we become so “selfie-centered” that unless it’s about us, we don’t care?

The answer is more complex than what we can decipher from observation. But what’s clear is that technology has changed human behavior, and video slideshows aren’t the novel and highly anticipated experiences that they used to be.

That makes me sad because I love to make slideshows - a love affair that started the moment I clicked “enable pan and zoom” in my first slideshow software. I later learned that what I had in my hands was a tool called the Ken Burns effect. This practice of manipulating a still image so that it appears to move was made famous after the documentary maker used it extensively in his production “The Civil War” and had only still images to work with.

Perhaps there’s more inspiration to be gleaned from Ken Burns. In his documentaries he does more than present a stream of photos. He gives his audience a way to take meaning from the images with a spoken narration.

The tools we need to make documentary-like videos are readily available, but it’s intimidating to think about emulating Ken Burns. It’s one thing to learn how to manipulate images and audio. It’s another to be able to uncover and craft the story.

Stories are exactly what we need more of. Maybe stories are what we need to capture the attention of a society that is overloaded with content but shallow on meaning. That’s what would turn a few pictures of a girl in dance costumes into the story of how that girl discovered her confidence.

Lori Creighton

I'm Lori Creighton, a communicator who helps businesses and families tell the stories that connect them — through content marketing and through photo and media management.

Next
Next

Climbing Out from Under the Photo Pile